◆ Engineering
MECH 371 Concordia: why do control students misread stability?
Direct answer: MECH 371 Concordia students misread stability because a plot shows gain and phase while the exam asks about time behaviour. Coppens et al. (2016) surveyed over 150 Belgian students and found that most Bode plot problems persisted after lab instruction. Practise reading each plot against a time response, and confirm every weight in your own outline.
◆ Question 1 / 8 · Misreading stability
Why do students misread stability in MECH 371 Concordia?
Direct answer: Students misread stability because a plot is a second language: it encodes gain and phase, while the exam asks about overshoot and settling. Three studies on over 150, 101 and 51 students find the same gap between knowing a formula and reading what a diagram says.
A common belief in a first control course such as MECH 371 Concordia is that stability is a yes or no fact you read off one plot. The research points to a more fragile skill. Coppens et al. (2016) interviewed second-year electronics engineering students and then sent a questionnaire to over 150 students in Belgium. They found that students understand a phase shift but have problems with its direction, and that students "generally have no idea what a signal with two frequencies looks like in the time domain" (Coppens et al., 2016). Bode plots were also a problem, because students could not construct one from a set of dummy measurements, and most of these issues persisted after lab instruction.
Marin et al. (2020) describe the same pattern in a master's automatic control course at Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso with 101 students: students often struggle to interpret what control diagrams show and to link it with theory. Nasr et al. (2005) ran clinical interviews with 51 students in an MIT Signals and Systems course and identified typical difficulties and the mathematical thinking behind them.
| Study | Sample | What students struggled with |
|---|---|---|
| Coppens et al. (2016) | Over 150 students, Belgium | Phase direction, two-frequency signals, building a Bode plot |
| Marin et al. (2020) | 101 students, Chile | Interpreting diagrams and linking them to theory |
| Nasr et al. (2005) | 51 students, MIT | Typical misconceptions in signals and systems |
Source: the three studies above, as listed in References.
◆ Question 2 / 8 · Coverage
What does MECH 371 at Concordia cover, and which courses come first?
Direct answer: MECH 371 Analysis and Design of Control Systems is a 3.75 credit course in the Mechanical Engineering core, preceded by PHYS 205, ENGR 243 and ENGR 311. Confirm the prerequisites for your intake year, because the older sources we found do not agree.
The Concordia calendar lists MECH 371 Concordia inside a Mechanical Engineering core of 87 credits within a 120 credit BEng (Concordia University, 2026). Each week brings 3 hours of lecture and 1 hour of tutorial, with a 3 hour laboratory on alternate weeks. The calendar states that "The laboratory work presents the opportunity to experiment with actual control systems hardware" (Concordia University, 2026), and the topic list runs through modelling, block diagrams, time domain analysis, linearization, transfer functions, stability, root locus, frequency response, PID design and Matlab with Simulink. Concordia offers it within the Gina Cody School of Engineering and Computer Science.
Prerequisites differ by source. The calendar reads "PHYS 205; ENGR 243, ENGR 311", while a third-party copy of a W2024 outline reads ENGR 311 and MECH 370. We could not verify whether MECH 370 left the core in 2026, so check your own degree audit before you plan a term. Later courses list it too: two read "ELEC 372 or MECH 371".
◆ Question 3 / 8 · Assessment
How is MECH 371 assessed, and why do the published weights disagree?
Direct answer: We could not verify the 2026 weights, and the public sources disagree: the final ranges from 50% to 60%. Plan around the outline your instructor posts in week one, and treat every percentage below as an old or unofficial reference point.
The table sets two published splits for MECH 371 Concordia side by side. Both come from sources we could not tie to the current term.
| Source | Final | Midterm | Lab | Assignments |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Undated instructor page (2001 textbook) | 60% | 25% | 10% | 5% |
| Third-party copy of the W2024 outline | 50% | 30% | 10% | 10% |
Two published MECH 371 grade splits, side by side
Both come from sources we could not tie to the current term, so confirm the weights in your own outline.
Final
60
% of the grade
Midterm
25
% of the grade
Lab
10
% of the grade
Assignments
5
% of the grade
Save this figure

Source: an undated instructor outline and a Course Sidekick copy of the W2024 outline, read 2026-10-31. Neither is the 2026 outline.
The W2024 copy also describes a pass rule that needs both the cumulative score and the final examination to be above 50%, as quoted on that third-party copy. Because the copy is secondary and two years old, do not assume the rule applies to you. Ask your instructor, or read the section of your outline on passing criteria.
The lab carries 10% in both splits, so it is a separate component and not a bonus. The 2017 lab manual on the Concordia server describes six labs, one every two weeks, and states "No late lab reports will be accepted" (Concordia University, 2017). Late work is therefore a risk you control, while weights are a fact you must confirm.
◆ Question 4 / 8 · The lab report
What does the lab ask you to show, and how should you write the report?
Direct answer: The 2017 manual builds the course around six labs on the MS150 DC motor trainer. Write each report as a comparison of prediction and measurement, and confirm the exact deliverables, error sources and any dead-band discussion in the manual your section uses.
The MECH 371 Concordia lab manual we found is dated 1/9/2017, so it may differ from the version in your section (Concordia University, 2017). What we could not verify is the detail of each lab, so we do not list error sources as if the manual required them. The advice below is MAAS method, not course policy.
Start with the prediction. Before the session, solve the model you will test and write down the response you expect. Then record what the hardware does, and treat the difference as your finding. A report that says the results "differ slightly" has not yet analysed anything. A stronger discussion names a candidate cause, such as friction in the motor, sensor noise or a limit on the actuator, and explains one measurement that would test it.
Lab-teaching research supports checking understanding in small steps. Chen et al. (2018) compared biweekly formative electronic lab assessments with traditional lab reports in a computer engineering laboratory course with N = 68 and report statistically significant effects on both learning outcomes and student satisfaction. That is a different discipline and course, so read it as a reason to self-test after every lab, not as a MECH 371 rule.
◆ Question 5 / 8 · MATLAB and Simulink
Do MATLAB and Simulink improve how you interpret results?
Direct answer: Simulation helped interpretation more than calculation in the one controlled study we found. Marin et al. (2020) compared two simulation tools with 101 students and found the real gains in reading transient response, steady state and Bode plots, not in arithmetic.
Marin et al. (2020) compared two simulation tools with 101 students. We could not open the full text to check the figures, so treat the statistics below as reported by the authors. A one-tailed independent t-test on global exam scores gave p = 0.032 with Cohen's d of 0.2, which the authors call a small effect. After Bonferroni correction, only three indicators stayed significant: interpretation of transient response, of steady state and of Bode plots, with medium, large and small effect sizes. Calculation indicators showed no meaningful difference.
Evidence for any teaching tool in this field is thin, so keep your own expectations modest. Reck et al. (2019) found no significant differences in the achievement of learning objectives or in student experience when a low-cost portable laboratory kit was used in an introductory control systems course. Hardware choice matters less than whether you explain the response you see.
| Marin et al. (2020) finding | Value |
|---|---|
| Students in the study | 101 |
| Global exam scores | p = 0.032, d = 0.2 |
| Significant after Bonferroni | Transient, steady state, Bode interpretation |
| Calculation indicators | No meaningful difference |
Source: Marin et al. (2020), open access under CC BY 4.0.
The practical reading is simple. In MECH 371 Concordia, use MATLAB-style tools to look at a response and say what it means, because that is where the measurable benefit sat.
◆ Question 6 / 8 · Frequency response
How should you study frequency response and root locus?
Direct answer: Study frequency response last and slowest. Yao (2020) describes the links between frequency response and time-domain performance as hard to follow for students, so solve each plant both ways, with a Routh array and then a Bode plot, to check yourself.
Yao (2020) describes the connections between frequency response characteristics such as gain margin and bandwidth and time-domain performance as empirical, which students can find confusing. That explains why the Bode plot feels harder than the root locus: the first links to time behaviour only through rules of thumb, while the second shows pole paths directly.
Here is a second MAAS illustration, again invented for practice and not a Concordia assignment. Take G(s) = K / (s(s + 2)(s + 5)) in a unity feedback loop. The characteristic equation is s^3 + 7s^2 + 10s + K = 0. The Routh array gives a first-column entry of (70 - K) / 7 in the s^1 row, so the loop is stable for 0 < K < 70. Now check the Bode plot: the phase crosses -180 degrees at 3.16 rad/s, where the magnitude equals K / 70. At K = 10 the gain margin is therefore 7, or about 16.9 dB, and at K = 70 it is exactly 1, or 0 dB, which agrees with the Routh boundary.
If the three methods disagree for your own plant, you have found an arithmetic slip yourself. Keep the PID controller as the common target, since PID design is a listed topic in the calendar. For a related method-choice habit, see how the ENGR 391 numerical methods guide asks you to justify a method, and the MECH 343 guide for another mechanical course.
◆ Question 7 / 8 · Study numbers
What do control education studies measure, in numbers?
Direct answer: Nine studies give numbers or sample sizes that bear on control courses, from 51 students to over 150. Most show that interpretation and lab design matter more than tools. Each setting differs from MECH 371, so read these as pointers, not predictions for your section.
The table lists each finding with its sample, country or level where the source states it, and what it means for your preparation.
| Study | Sample and setting | What it reports | Use for MECH 371 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coppens et al. (2016) | Over 150 students, Belgium | Phase direction and Bode construction problems persist after labs | Draw a Bode plot from raw numbers |
| Marin et al. (2020) | 101 students, Chile | Gains in interpreting transient, steady state and Bode plots | Explain each plot in words |
| Nasr et al. (2005) | 51 students, MIT | Typical misconceptions found by clinical interview | Revise signals first |
| Chen et al. (2018) | N = 68, computer engineering lab | Biweekly formative assessments beat weekly lab reports | Quiz yourself after each lab |
| Chevalier et al. (2017) | Three years of feedback, remote lab, two applications | Exam results measured the remote laboratory | Labs feed exam skills |
| Lei et al. (2021) | Multiyear evaluation, networked control lab | Higher final score in two class modules | Use interactive demos |
| Reck et al. (2019) | Introductory control course, portable kit | No significant differences in objectives or experience | Low-cost kits are no handicap |
| Vahdatikhaki et al. (2024) | 92 students, civil engineering | Virtual-lab users spent 16% less physical lab time | Prepare virtually first |
| Leydens et al. (2021) | Focus groups and interviews over 3 years | Three interrelated domains on social justice | Expect questions about people, not only plants |
Source: the studies linked in the table, read 2026-11-02. Details are those in the published abstracts.
◆ Question 8 / 8 · Common mistakes
Which three mistakes recur in MECH 371 work, and what backs each one?
Direct answer: The three recurring mistakes are misjudging phase direction, trusting a simulation without interpreting it, and treating the lab report as a description. Each one maps to a published finding, and each can be checked in 15 minutes before you submit.
First, misjudging phase direction. Coppens et al. (2016) found that students understand a phase shift but have problems with its direction. Before you state a margin, say aloud whether the output leads or lags the input.
Second, trusting a simulation without interpretation. Marin et al. (2020) found that simulation gains showed up in interpreting transient response, steady state and Bode plots, while calculation indicators did not differ. A MATLAB step plot with no sentence about overshoot or settling is a number without a meaning.
Here is an illustration written by MAAS, not a Concordia case and not research data. A second-order system with natural frequency 4 rad/s and damping ratio 0.5 has a percent overshoot of exp(-pi x 0.5 / sqrt(1 - 0.25)), which is about 16.3%, and a 2% settling time near 4 / (0.5 x 4) = 2 seconds. If your Bode or step plot suggests a very different overshoot, you have found a slip before the marker does.
Third, writing the lab as a description. Chen et al. (2018) found that biweekly formative assessments gave better outcomes than traditional reports in a course with N = 68. The lesson is to test your understanding after each lab, then write the report from your own prediction versus measurement gap. With six labs in the 2017 manual and a rule against late reports, the cheapest protection is a fixed weekly slot for self-checking.
Frequently asked questions
How many credits is MECH 371 at Concordia?
It is 3.75 credits, with 3 hours of lecture and 1 hour of tutorial weekly and a 3 hour lab on alternate weeks, according to the Concordia calendar.
What are the prerequisites for MECH 371?
The calendar lists PHYS 205, ENGR 243 and ENGR 311. Confirm with your degree audit, because a W2024 copy also names MECH 370.
Is the final worth 50% or 60%?
We could not verify the 2026 weights. An undated instructor page gives 60% and a W2024 copy gives 50%, so use the outline your instructor posts.
Why do students struggle with Bode plots?
Coppens et al. (2016) found that students could not construct a Bode plot from measurements and that most issues persisted after lab instruction.
Can an expert do my lab report for me?
No. An expert reads your own report and your own reasoning, then points to weak spots, while you make the changes and stay responsible for the work.
A second reader for your MECH 371 lab report and problem sets
If you want feedback on MECH 371 Concordia work before you submit, a MAAS tutor can walk through a method you cannot yet explain, for example reading margin from a Bode plot, in a one to one session through subject tutoring. Tutoring is advisory, carries no grade target, and you can ask to change expert if the fit is wrong. For feedback on your own draft in stages, see coursework and assignment support, which follows Outline, Draft, Final with you staying involved.
Related guides
- ENGR 391 Numerical Methods in Engineering: another Concordia engineering course where the method has to be justified
- ENGR 301 Engineering Management Principles and Economics: the engineering core course from a different department
- MECH 343 guide: another mechanical engineering course guide
- How to revise for final exams effectively: timed practice for a heavily weighted final
References
- Chen, B., DeMara, R. F., Salehi, S., & Hartshorne, R. (2018). Elevating Learner Achievement Using Formative Electronic Lab Assessments in the Engineering Laboratory: A Viable Alternative to Weekly Lab Reports. IEEE Transactions on Education, 61(1), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1109/te.2017.2706667
- Chevalier, A., Copot, C., Ionescu, C., & De Keyser, R. (2017). A Three-Year Feedback Study of a Remote Laboratory Used in Control Engineering Studies. IEEE Transactions on Education, 60(2), 127–133. https://doi.org/10.1109/te.2016.2605080
- Concordia University. (2017). MECH 371 laboratory manual [PDF]. https://users.encs.concordia.ca/~bwgordon/mech371_lab_manual.pdf
- Concordia University. (2026). Mechanical engineering courses. In Undergraduate calendar 2026-2027. https://www.concordia.ca/academics/undergraduate/calendar/current/section-71-gina-cody-school-of-engineering-and-computer-science/section-71-60-engineering-course-descriptions/mechanical-engineering-courses.html
- Coppens, P., Van den Bossche, J., & De Cock, M. (2016). Student understanding of phase shifts, frequency and Bode plots. International Journal of Electrical Engineering & Education, 54(3), 247–261. https://doi.org/10.1177/0020720916680373
- Lei, Z., Zhou, H., Hu, W., Deng, Q., Zhou, D., Liu, Z. W., & Gao, X. (2021). 3-D Interactive Control Laboratory for Classroom Demonstration and Online Experimentation in Engineering Education. IEEE Transactions on Education, 64(3), 276–282. https://doi.org/10.1109/te.2020.3041070
- Leydens, J. A., Johnson, K. E., & Moskal, B. M. (2021). Engineering Student Perceptions of Social Justice in a Feedback Control Systems Course. Journal of Engineering Education, 110(3), 718–749. https://doi.org/10.1002/jee.20412
- Marin, L., Vargas, H., Heradio, R., de la Torre, L., Diaz, J. M., & Dormido, S. (2020). Evidence-based control engineering education: Evaluating the LCSD simulation tool. IEEE Access, 8, 170183-170194. https://doi.org/10.1109/ACCESS.2020.3023910
- Nasr, R., Hall, S. R., & Garik, P. (2005). Student misconceptions in signals and systems and their origins, Part II. Proceedings, 35th Annual Frontiers in Education Conference, T4E-26 to T4E-31. https://doi.org/10.1109/fie.2005.1611980
- Reck, R. M., Sreenivas, R. S., & Loui, M. C. (2019). Evaluating the Effectiveness of an Affordable and Portable Laboratory Kit for an Introductory Control Systems Course. Advances in Engineering Education. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1236922
- Faridaddin Vahdatikhaki, Ilona Friso-van den Bos, Sajad Mowlaei, & Bas Kollöffel (2024). Application of Gamified Virtual Laboratories as a Preparation Tool for Civil Engineering Students. European Journal of Engineering Education, 49(1), 164–191. https://doi.org/10.1080/03043797.2023.2265306
- Yao, J. (2020). Temperature control project that facilitates learning of difficult concepts in control theory. Advances in Engineering Education, 8(2). https://doi.org/10.18260/3-1-1115-36020
This article is part of the MAAS Journal series for students. MAAS is an academic support partner: experts guide students through each stage of their own work, and we do not complete assessed work on a student's behalf.
A free 20-minute consultation is a conversation about where you are with MECH371.
Book a free consultation ▸